Published claim files
The World against Israel Case
Evidence archive and research command center for claim files, source chains, public source links, and debunk packs.
Aurel Sari discusses a hypothetical attack on a protected hospital
Aurel Sari's hypothetical legal commentary, published on 19 October 2023 and hosted by the Lieber Institute. The quoted passage belongs to Scenario One, which assumes a deliberate attack on a hospital that is not a military objective; it is not a finding that this scenario occurred. Scenarios Two through Six separately discuss military use, warnings, proportionality, precautions, incidental harm, malfunctioning weapons and interception. In Back to reality the author favors a different account involving a Palestinian rocket; that dated assessment is author opinion, not independently established by this record. ICRC Customary IHL Rule 28 supplies context on protection of medical units, loss of protection for harmful acts outside humanitarian functions, and warning requirements (https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/customary-ihl/v1/rule28). This record verifies the published conditional passage only, not incident responsibility, intent, casualties, a war crime or any person's liability. The Institute is the host, Aurel Sari the author; the publisher disclaims endorsement and official US military policy.
Wallace and Reeves discuss foreseeable above-ground harm from tunnel attacks
Editorial paraphrase of David A. Wallace and Shane Reeves's written discussion dated 14 November 2023, hosted by the Lieber Institute; not a verbatim quotation of the DoD manual or institutional endorsement. The authors tentatively extend foreseeable civilian-harm analysis to effects above ground. Their surrounding analysis requires distinction, proportionality and feasible precautions, treats exclusively humanitarian tunnels as protected civilian objects, and includes civilian hostages in the analysis. The same article discusses defender obligations; these do not remove attacker obligations. Additional Protocol I Article 51(5)(b) and (8) supplies limiting context (https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/api-1977/article-51). The linked July 2023 DoD manual returned HTTP 403 during this review: its exact text and the authors' interpretation are not independently certified. This record verifies the authors' published discussion only. It does not establish any tunnel's use, foreseeability in a particular attack, casualties, proportionality, wrongdoing or legal liability. The publisher expressly disclaims endorsement and official US military policy.
Sky News attributed a tunnel-demolition video to Israel in its June 29, 2026 synopsis
Verified only as Sky News wording on June 29, 2026: the description attributes the clip to Israel and uses the qualification 'is said to show'. The video has not been independently authenticated, geolocated or reviewed here; tunnel ownership, weapons storage, scale, necessity and legality of the demolition are not established by this record. Same-day counter-context: L’Orient Today’s June 29 report, based in part on its southern correspondent, describes residents reporting damage and collapses around Majdal Zoun, attributes the military explanation to Israel and reports Hezbollah’s ceasefire objections. Those accounts remain attributed, not adjudicated findings. See https://today.lorientlejour.com/article/1539636/israel-claims-destroyed-200-meter-tunnel-in-overnight-majdal-zoun-demolition.html . This page is a record of a written media attribution, not verification of the underlying military claim or any party’s legal position.
OCHA summarized aid-shipment security concerns in its July report
This record verifies OCHA’s published summary, not the underlying incidents. The report is titled 10 July 2026 and visibly published on 11 July; the Gaza reporting period is 29 June to 5 July unless otherwise specified. The excerpt is Highlights bullet 6. The main text describes unidentified external actors placing non-humanitarian items in aid cargo, and people identifying themselves as agents of the de facto authorities conducting searches. OCHA reports one confiscation of small packages on two aid pallets during seven searches, with nothing found in the other six. These qualifications do not establish the identity, intent or criminal liability of any person or organization, diversion of humanitarian aid, or wrongdoing by aid workers. Independent inspection logs, seizure records and chain-of-custody evidence were not authenticated here. This source therefore cannot independently prove smuggling, confiscation legality or responsibility. The same report describes Israeli access restrictions, funding and supply shortages, and continuing assistance. Incoming Supplies says an Ashdod scanner problem was resolved on 2 July and Egypt-corridor offloading rose from 42 to 56 per cent; UN figures cover only supplies tracked through UN 2720. Annex 1 records ongoing food, water and medical assistance without establishing adequacy. The governed claim is limited to what OCHA published and the qualifications in its own report.
OCHA reported access and aid-chain concerns in its July humanitarian update
This record verifies what OCHA reported, not the underlying incidents or legal responsibility. The report is titled 10 July 2026 and visibly published on 11 July; the Gaza reporting period is 29 June to 5 July unless otherwise specified. The excerpt joins two separated passages with an explicit ellipsis. Omitted text includes a cross-reference to access-restricted areas and OCHA’s account of a World Central Kitchen announcement about a driver’s death on 8 July, outside the reporting period; this record does not independently establish that incident. In the intervening aid-chain account, OCHA described unidentified external actors and individuals identifying themselves as agents of the de facto authorities. It reported one confiscation involving small packages on two aid pallets during seven searches, with nothing found in the other six. These qualifications do not establish the identity, intent or criminal liability of any person or organization, diversion of humanitarian aid, or wrongdoing by aid workers. The full report describes multiple constraints, including funding and supply shortages, and continuing assistance. Incoming Supplies says an Ashdod scanner problem was resolved on 2 July and Egypt-corridor offloading rose from 42 to 56 per cent; UN figures cover only supplies tracked through UN 2720. Annex 1 records continued food, water and medical assistance, without establishing that assistance was adequate. Independent inspection logs, chain-of-custody evidence and responses from the authorities were not authenticated here. The governed claim is limited to OCHA’s published concerns and their stated limits; it makes no independent finding on access legality, smuggling, intent, causation or liability.
MSF published an explicit condemnation of Hamas attacks
This verifies MSF's own published condemnation, dated 18 June 2026. The casualty figure is MSF's wording, not a new casualty audit. The same answer expresses concern for both populations and retains MSF's criticism and legal characterization of Gaza; this record neither endorses nor refutes that characterization. Adjacent answers discuss hostage suffering, medical impartiality and hospital neutrality. The statement does not establish MSF's operational neutrality, settle allegations against its staff, or adjudicate any party's conduct.
OCHA relayed a reported Al Shifa dialysis shortage in July 2026
This is a dated attribution to OCHA, which explicitly relays Gaza Ministry of Health reporting; it is not an independent clinical audit. The source describes underfunding and consumable shortages, approximately 25 of 52 machines out of service, and emergency measures maintaining partial coverage. About 240 is the affected patient caseload, not a death count. The Gaza reporting period is 22-28 June unless specified; publication is 4 July. No patient records or independent supply audit were provided. The report also describes continuing Health Cluster work with partners and donors. No finding of deliberate deprivation, responsibility, crime or current clinical status is made.